KOL Pulse — Trial Profile

CRITICS-II Trial

Resectable gastric cancer (preoperative-only regimen selection) — Dutch investigator-initiated cooperative group (16 Netherlands centers)

Resectable gastric cancer (preoperative-only regimen selection)Strategy trial — no single agentASCO GI 2026 (#ASCOGI26)
Visit Interactive Trial Page →

Top KOLs Discussing CRITICS-II

Dr Rishabh Jain
Dr Rishabh Jain
@DrRishabhOnco
22.8K impressions
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford
@NiuSanford
19.4K impressions
Garrett Green, MD
Garrett Green, MD
@ggreen1986
3.1K impressions
Nieves Martinez Lago MD PhD
Nieves Martinez Lago MD PhD
@DraMartinezLago
3K impressions
Jun Gong
Jun Gong
@jgong15
2.7K impressions
Arndt Vogel
Arndt Vogel
@ArndtVogel
1.3K impressions

CRITICS-II Key Slides & Visuals

Official trial slides and relevant visuals shared by KOLs at ASCO GI 2026 (#ASCOGI26). Click any image to expand.

Dr Rishabh Jain
Dr Rishabh Jain @DrRishabhOnco
CRITICS-II Data
14.6K impressions · 136 likes · Jan 8, 2026
View on X ↗
[Slide 1] CRITICS-II Neoadjuvant Strategies in Resectable Gastric Cancer Phase II | ASCO GI 2026 @DrRishabhOnco All treatment before surgery Arm 1 Arm 2 Arm 3 Chemotherapy Chemotherapy Chemoraditerapy Alone Chemoraditherapy Alone 1-yr EFS: 1-yr EFS: 1-yr EFS: 68% 84% 78% Failed 1-yr OS: Best efficacy 89% compliance threshold Higher toxicity 1-yr EFS: 84% 1-yr EFS: 78% 1-yr OS: 89% Best compliance pCR: 20% (highest) Lowest toxicity Key message Chemotherapy alone is insufficient. Total neoadjuvant therapy shows strongest efficacy. CRT alone remains a well-tolerated alternative.
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford @NiuSanford
CRITICS-II Data
12.4K impressions · 72 likes · Jan 8, 2026
View on X ↗
[Slide 1] CRITICS Trial design Chemotherapy D2 surgery 4x DOC R Chemotherapy Chemoradiation D2 surgery 2x DOC 45 Gy + 5x PC Chemoradiation 45 Gy + 5x PC D2 surgery Tissue & blood banking - - HRQOL Stratified for: Center, Histological type Slagter et al. BMC Cancer 2018 ASCO Gastrointestinal #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY Cancers Symposium Presentation is property of the author and ASCO Permission required for reuse, contact permissions@asco.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER --- [Slide 2] CRITICS Results: Study Profile Underwent R Started Completed pre-operative treatment curative Completed surgery treatment surgery n=68 4x DOC Surgery n=54 100% n=55 (81%) n=62 n=60 (79%) n=65 2x DOC (n=60) CRT 5x PC (n=43); 45 Gy (n=51) Surgery n=41 n=201 100% n=42 (65%) n=60 n=58 (63%) n=68 CRT 5x PC (n=58); 45 Gy (n=64) Surgery n=53 100% n=57 (84%) n=63 n=63 (78%) ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CUNICAL ONCOLOGY Presentation is property of the author and ASCO Permission required for reuse, contact permissions@asco.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER --- [Slide 3] 16 Results: Pathology (2) Arm 1: DOC Arm 2: DOC+CRT Arm 3: CRT Total n=62 (%) n=60 (%) n=63 (%) n=185 (%) Tumor regression grade TRG 1 (pCR) 4 (8) 10 (20) 7 (13) 21 (13) TRG 2 9 (17) 13 (25) 16 (30) 38 (24) TRG 3 11 (21) 12 (24) 18 (33) 41 (26) TRG 4 15 (28) 10 (20) 10 (19) 35 (22) TRG 5 (no response) 14 (26) 6 (12) 3 (6) 23 (15) Missing 9 9 9 27 Radicality of resection R0 53 (98) 50 (91) 56 (93) 159 (94) R1 1 (2) 5 (9) 4 (7) 10 (6) Missing 8 5 3 16 Number of lymph nodes Median (range) 31 (14 - 83) 23 (0 42) 21 (8 47) 25 (0 - 83) Central review in progress ASCO Gastrointestinal #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY Cancers Symposium Presentation a property of the author and ASCO Permission required for reuse; contact permissions@asco.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER --- [Slide 4] CRITICS Results: Event-Free Survival Strata DOC surgery DOC CRT surgery CRT surgery 1.00 0.75 Survival probability 0.50 Arm 1-year EFS 95% CI (%) (%) 0.25 1: DOC 68 58 - 80 2: DOC+CRT 84 75 94 0.00 3: CRT 78 69 - 88 0 12 24 36 48 60 72 Time (months) Number at risk DOC surgery 68 45 33 23 12 6 0 Strata DOC CRT surgery 65 51 34 26 14 6 0 CRT surgery 68 52 36 24 13 5 0 0 12 24 36 48 60 72 Time (months) ASCO Gastrointestinal #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY Cancers Symposium Presentation is property of the author and ASCO Permission required for reuse, contact permissions@asco.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER
Dr Rishabh Jain
Dr Rishabh Jain @DrRishabhOnco
CRITICS-II Data
8.1K impressions · 78 likes · Jan 8, 2026
View on X ↗
[Slide 1] CRITICS Trial design Chemotherapy D2 surgery 4x DOC R Chemotherapy Chemoradiation D2 surgery 2x DOC 45 Gy + 5x PC Chemoradiation 45 Gy + 5x PC D2 surgery Tissue & blood banking - HRQOL Stratified for: Center, Histological type Slagter et al. BMC Cancer 2018 ASCO Gastrointestinal #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY Cancers Symposium Presentation is property of the author and ASCO Permission required for reuse, contact permissions@asco.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER --- [Slide 2] CRITICS Results: Study Profile Underwent R Started Completed pre-operative treatment curative Completed surgery treatment surgery n=68 4x DOC Surgery n=54 100% n=55 (81%) n=62 n=60 (79%) n=65 2x DOC (n=60) CRT 5x PC (n=43); 45 Gy (n=51) Surgery n=41 n=201 100% n=42 (65%) n=60 n=58 (63%) n=68 CRT 5x PC (n=58); 45 Gy (n=64) Surgery n=53 100% n=57 (84%) n=63 n=63 (78%) ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY Presentation 5 property of the author and ASCO Permission required for reuse; contact permissions@asco.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER --- [Slide 3] CRITICS-II Outcomes Event-Free Survival Overall Survival 100 100 80 80 DOC + CRT + surgery DOC + CRT + surgery 60 60 EFS OS HHHH (%) DOC + surgery (%) 40 40 DOC + surgery CRT + surgery CRT + surgery 20 20 0 0 0 12 24 36 48 60 72 0 12 24 36 48 60 72 Months Months No. at risk No. at risk DOC + surgery 68 45 33 23 12 6 0 DOC surgery 68 47 35 24 14 7 0 DOC * CRT + surgery 65 51 34 26 14 6 0 DOC CRT surgery 65 53 37 28 16 7 0 CRT + surgery 68 52 36 24 13 5 0 CRT surgery 68 54 37 26 15 7 0 ASCO Gastrointestinal Christopher L. Hallemeier, M.D. ASCO or PRESENTED BY CHRICAL #GI26 Cancers Symposium KNOWLIDGE CONQUES CANCER Presentation . property of be author and ASCO Permission required for reuse, contact --- [Slide 4] CRITICS Results: overview Parameter (%) Arm 1: DOC Arm 2: DOC+CRT Arm 3: CRT 1-year EFS (>75%) 68 84 78 1-year OS 74 89 84 Pre-operative compliance 81 65 84 Pre-operative toxicity grade 3-5 56 55 43 Surgery related complications 21 15 21 Pathological complete response 8 20 13 Considering survival, surgical complications and pathological response rates, "total neoadjuvant" chemotherapy plus chemoradiotherapy is identified as preferred pre-operative regimen ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Canoer Institute/Radboud university modical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO SOCIETY - COMPAE - Presentation is property of the any and ASCO Purchase required for result, contact CHOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford @NiuSanford
CRITICS-II Data
6.8K impressions · 67 likes · Jan 9, 2026
View on X ↗
[Slide 1] TPS Abstract 464: An open label phase 2 study of Total Neoadjuvant Therapy (TNT) consisting of FLOT with pembrolizumab and short radiation for patients with locally advanced gastroesophageal junction adenocarcinoma (EPOC2301) Kazuma Sato Izuma Nakayama Masahiro Yurs Akihiro Sato Mitsuko Suzuki Tomohiro Kadota Masaki Nakamura Nacya Sakamoto", Tadayoshi Hashimoton, Shingo Sakashita Masashi Wakabayash Hirokazu Shojint, EPOC Tsutomu Hayashi Hroyuki Dalko Ken Kato Takayuki Yoshino Tomonon Yano", alleo Fujta", Takahiro Kinoshita Kohei Shitara Division of sophageal Surgery National Cancer Center Hospital East (NOCE) Japan Dept of Gastroenterology and Gastrointestinal Oncology NOCE, Japan Dept. of Gastric Surgery NOCE Japan 4) Clinical Research Support office NCCE Japan Dept. Gastroenterslogy and Endoscopy NCCE Japan, 4) Dept of Radiation Onoology NCCE Japan Dept. of Pathology and Cinical Laboratories, NOCE, Japan #) Dept. for the Promotion of Drug and Diagnostic Development NCCE, Japan Dept. of Gastrointestinal Medical Oneslogy NCC, Japan, 10) Dept of Gastric Surgery NCC, Japan, 11), Dept of Eaophageal Surgery NCC Japan (2) Dept of read and Neck, Esophages Medical Oneology NCC Hospital, Japan EPOC2301 (ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT07018570)/jRCT 2031250089) A multicenter, open-label, phase II study investigating TNT with FLOT plus pembrolizumab and Background 25Gy of SRT in patients with resectable GEJA. This figure was created using BioRender materials and customized Perioperative FLOT (fluorouracil, leucovorin, oxaliplatin, and docetaxel) has been established as the standard of care for Immuno- Immuno- resectable upper gastrointestinal adenocarcinoma based on the FLOT4 and ESOPEC trials 1.2. chemotherapy Radiation chemotherapy 2 Key eligible criteria The phase III MATTERHORN trial demonstrated that the addition of durvalumab to FLOT (D-FLOT) significantly improved Gastroesophageal junction adenocarcinoma event-free survival (EFS) and overall survival (OS) in patients with resectable gastric and gastroesophageal junction Pembrolizumab (Siewert Type I-III) adenocarcinoma (GEJA). leading to FDA approval of D-FLOT3. cT2-4:1 any, MO Aged 18 years or older FLOT Despite these advances, surgical resection remains required for all patients and is associated with considerable ECOG postoperative morbidity and reduced QOL 4.5. FLOT Cocetaint mg/ml, Primary endpoint: 3-year EFS Osaliptatin mg/ml D-FLOT achieved a pathological complete response (pCR) in approximately 20% of patients, suggesting that a subset of Levololinate 200 Secondary endpoints SFU mg/ml (v) 01 15 22 01 15 individuals may achieve cure without surgery. organ-sparing survival, 05. clinical response rate, (CR rate, MPR rate pCR rate, radical resection rate, 200 regidose (v) 25Gy/5tr Increasing the clinical complete response (cCR) rate through intensified TNT with short-course radiation (SRT) could TNT completion rate, treatment completion rate, AE. allow non-operative management (NOM) in carefully selected patients with resectable locally advanced GEJA. dona clearance EORTC QLO C30, and Q-0G25 Response evaluation 2 Yes Immunochemotherapy.as NOM CT scan Serial CIDNA monitoring Endoscopy (bite-on-bite) Methods PET-CT cCR/near CR Response evaluation 1 Blood test (Tumor markers) " CIDNA The major inclusion criteria CT scan Pembrolizumab No (i) histologically confirmed adenocarcinoma of the GEJ (Siewert type I-III), (ii) cT22 and/or N+, MO according to the 8th PETCT Yes edition of the UICC-TNM classification, (iii) age 2 18 years, (iv) Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group Performance Status FLOT of 0 or 1, (vi) no prior systemic chemotherapy, (vii) adequate organ functions. Surgery 6 15 22 29 43 17 Endoscopy cCR/near CR Treatment details (bite biopsy) <Immunochemotherapy 1 and 2> Blood (fumor markers (IDNA) No Postoperative immunochemotherapy Two cycles of FLOT (docetaxel 50 mg/m2, oxaliplatin 85 mg/m2, levofolinate 200 mg/m2, 5-FU 2600 mg/m2, administer 4 doses at 14-day intervals starting from day 1) and two dose of pembrolizumab (200 mg/dose, administer at 21-day intervals Serial CIDNA monitoring starting from day1), followed by RT, then an additional two cycles of FLOT and one dose of pembrolizumab. <Short course radiation therapy (SRT)> A total dose of 25 Gy in 5 fractions was delivered to the tumor and involved lymph nodes, without elective nodal irradiation. References and Acknowledgements A 3.0-cm margin for the primary lesion and 0.5-1.0 cm for lymph nodes were added to the gross tumor volume to define the clinical target volume (CTV). An additional margin of 0.5-1.0 cm was applied to both primary and nodal CTVs to account for internal motion and setup uncertainties. Radiotherapy was delivered with IMRT and daily image guidance. 1. Al-Batran SE. Homann N. Pauligk C. Goetze TO. Meiler J. Kasper S. et at Lancet 2019;393(10184):1948-57. 2. Hoeppner J. Brunner T. Schmoor C. Bronsert P. Kulemann B. Claus R, et al. N Engl Med 2025,392(4) 323-35 <immunochemotherapy as NOM or post-operative immunochemotherapy> 3. Janjigian YY, Al-Batran SE, Wainberg 2A Muro K, Molena D. Van Cutsem E. et at N Engl Med 2025,393(3) 217-30 4. Mine S. Kurokawa Y. Takeuchi H, Terashima M. Yasuda T. Yoshida K. et at Gastric Cancer 2022;25(2) 430-7. Four cycles of FLOT and 3 doses of pembrolizumab followed by 10 doses of pembrolizumab. 5. Fuchs H, Holscher AH, Leers J. Bludau M. Brinkmann S. Schröder W, et al. Gastric Cancer 2016;19(1)312-7. Sample size and statistical analysis Acknowledgments We are grateful to all participating patients, their families, all investigators involved in the EPOC2301, and Merck & Co., Inc. When calculated using the exact method based on a binomial distribution with a threshold 3-year EFS of 46%, expected Funding value of 70%, one-sided alpha of 10%, and power of 80%, the number of patients required would be 24. The target number MSD K.K., Tokyo. Japan provided financial support and drug. of patients was set at 26, considering a few ineligible patients.
Garrett Green, MD
Garrett Green, MD @ggreen1986
CRITICS-II Data
3.1K impressions · 33 likes · Jan 8, 2026
View on X ↗
[Slide 1] CRITICS Results: Event-Free Survival Strata DOC surgery DOC CRT surgery CRT surgery 1.00 0.75 Survival probability 0.50 Arm 1-year EFS 95% CI (%) (%) 0.25 1: DOC 68 58 80 2: DOC+CRT 84 75 - 94 0.00 3: CRT 78 69 88 0 12 24 36 48 60 72 Time (months) Number at risk DOC . surgery 68 45 33 23 12 6 0 Strata DOC CRT surgery 65 51 34 26 14 6 0 CRT surgery 68 52 36 24 13 5 0 0 12 24 36 48 60 72 Time (months) ASCO Gastrointestinal #GI26 PRESENTED BY Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN 30C ETY OF CLINICAL GRODUCT Cancers Symposium Presentation property of the euthor and ASCO Permission required for reuse, contact CHOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium --- [Slide 2] CRITICS Results: Study Profile Underwent R Started Completed pre-operative treatment curative Completed surgery treatment surgery n=68 4x DOC Surgery n=54 100% n=55 (81%) n=62 n=60 (79%) n=65 n=201 2x DOC (n=60) CRT 5x PC (n=43); 45 Gy (n=51) Surgery n=41 100% n=42 (65%) n=60 n=58 (63%) n=68 CRT 5x PC (n=58); 45 Gy (n=64) Surgery n=53 100% n=57 (84%) n=63 n=63 (78%) ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium #GI26 PRESENTED BY: Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY Presentation property of the - and ASCO Permission required or - contact permissions@ase.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium --- [Slide 3] Gastric Cancer When to consider nCRT, usually after initial FLOT +- 10* Anatomic Biological Conditional Risk for R1 Equivocal M1 PS decline with chemo cT4 Poor response to Age/comorbidities chemo ? surgical candidate *Based on oncological principles, not phase 3 RCTs Patients should be discussed in multi-D manner Clinical trials when appropriate ASCO Gastrointestinal #GI26 PRESENTED BY Christopher L. Hallemeier, M.D. ASCO CONTRAL GNODLOGY Cancers Symposium Presentation is property of the author and ASCO Person required for reuse contact permissions@asco.com KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium --- [Slide 4] CRITICS Summary (1) CRITICS-II compares 3 pre-operative regimens without adjuvant treatment Pre-operative compliance rate was high (77%), and most favorable after chemotherapy alone and after chemoradiotherapy alone Pre-operative toxicity was lowest after chemoradiotherapy alone Surgical quality was excellent with 91% undergoing ≥ D1+ dissection and removal of a median of 25 lymph nodes Surgery related complications were acceptable, being lowest after chemotherapy plus chemoradiotherapy (15%) ASCO Gastrointestinal #GI26 PRESENTED BY Marcel Verheij MD PhD, Netherlands Cancer Institute/Radboud university medical center, CRITICS-II trial ASCO AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CLINICAL CANCOLOGY Cancers Symposium Presentation property two author and ASCO Permission required for reuse, contact permissions@gue.co.org KNOWLEDGE CONQUERS CANCER ASCO Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium

CRITICS-II Top Tweets

Top tweets by impressions — click to view on X

Dr Rishabh Jain
Dr Rishabh Jain@DrRishabhOnco

🚨 Resectable Gastric Cancer | #GI26

CRITICS-II answers a key question
What is the best preoperative strategy when adjuvant therapy is omitted?

🧪 Trial design
Three fully neoadjuvant approaches…

👁 14.6K ♡ 136 ↻ 60 Jan 8, 2026
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford@NiuSanford

CRITICS-II: multicenter Ph2 RCT in resectable gastric ca showing preop chemo (DOC) + CRT improved 1-yr EFS &amp; pCR (20%) v CRT or chemo alone. But w D-FLOT now SOC, q’s are:

1. Could adding…

👁 12.4K ♡ 72 ↻ 36 Jan 8, 2026
Dr Rishabh Jain
Dr Rishabh Jain@DrRishabhOnco

📊 CRITICS-II at #ASCOGI26

Total neoadjuvant therapy wins the pre-op race in resectable gastric cancer 🍽️🩺

3 strategies tested head-to-head
🧪 Chemo alone
🔥 Chemoradiation alone
🚀 Chemo ➜…

👁 8.1K ♡ 78 ↻ 40 Jan 8, 2026
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford@NiuSanford

Here is a great trial already in progress building off MATTERHORN &amp; CRITICS-II (presented today)!

Japanese EPOC2031 Ph2: TNT for resectable GEJ
-FLOT + pembro + short course RT (25 Gy/5fx)

-1…

👁 6.8K ♡ 67 ↻ 20 Jan 9, 2026
Garrett Green, MD
Garrett Green, MD@ggreen1986

CRITICS - II: TNT for Gastric Cancer?! When do we consider chemorads #ASCOGI26 #GI26 https://t.co/bXjddANLlC

👁 3.1K ♡ 33 ↻ 14 Jan 8, 2026
Nieves Martinez Lago MD PhD
Nieves Martinez Lago MD PhD@DraMartinezLago

#GI26 CRITICS-II (phase II) | Resectable GC
🔀 3 neoadj strategies tested (no adj therapy):
• CT alone (failed EFS threshold)
• CT → CRT (TNT)
• CRT alone
📈 1-yr EFS: 84% (CT+CRT) vs 78% (CRT) vs 68%…

👁 3K ♡ 48 ↻ 25 Jan 8, 2026
Jun Gong
Jun Gong@jgong15

Dr. Hallemeier excellent discussion on CRITICS-II vs TOPGEAR, noting differences in absence of IO &amp; periop vs TNT approaches between studies including study heterogeneity. Important for further…

👁 1.4K ♡ 22 ↻ 10 Jan 8, 2026
Jun Gong
Jun Gong@jgong15

Dr. Verheij CRITICS-II rand PhII pick-the-winner neoadj tx strategies in resectable #GC/GEJC ➡️ total neoadjuvant chemo + chemoRT w/best outcomes &amp; preferred candidate for further study, notably…

👁 1.3K ♡ 22 ↻ 7 Jan 8, 2026
Arndt Vogel
Arndt Vogel@ArndtVogel

CRITICS-II: Phase II trial of neo-adjuvant CTx vs neo-adjuvant CTx and subsequent CTR vs neo-adjuvant chemoradiotherapy followed by surgery in resectable GC
#ASCOGI26
👉 Arm1: lowest efficacy
👉…

👁 1.3K ♡ 19 ↻ 3 Jan 9, 2026
Mustafa Özdoğan, MD
Mustafa Özdoğan, MD@ozdogan_md

#ASCOGI26 | CRITICS-II (Abstract 283)

Can we finally solve the post-op drop-out problem in gastric cancer?

Total neoadjuvant therapy (chemo → chemoradiotherapy → surgery) shows higher 1-year EFS…

👁 330 ♡ 3 ↻ 2 Jan 9, 2026

About the CRITICS-II Trial

Phase 2 'pick-the-winner' trial — CT + CRT arm selected for phase 3 evaluation in resectable gastric cancer. Shifts attention back to preoperative chemoradiotherapy after CRITICS-I (phase 3) showed no benefit for postoperative CRT. Does not change current practice but informs phase 3 design.

Trial Methodology & Results

1-year Event-Free Survival (EFS) — Primary Endpoint

Three-arm pick-the-winner design comparing preoperative regimens. CT alone: 1-yr EFS 68% (below 75% threshold). CT + CRT: 1-yr EFS 84%. CRT alone: 1-yr EFS 78%. Winner = CT + CRT based on EFS, OS, surgical outcomes, and pCR. Median follow-up 40.4 months.

CT+CRT selected for phase 3 (1-yr EFS 84%)

📄 Source: KOL commentary on X →

Overall Survival (OS)

1-year OS rates: CT alone 74%, CT+CRT 89%, CRT alone 84%. Pick-the-winner design — not powered for formal OS comparison between arms.


📄 Source →

Safety & Tolerability

Preoperative regimen safety profile detailed in primary publication. Pick-the-winner design focuses on 1-year EFS landmark rather than extensive toxicity comparison.

Safety profiles support phase 3 evaluation of CT+CRT arm

📄 Source →

Clinical Implications

⚠️ Phase 2 pick-the-winner — informs phase 3 design, not current practice. Phase 2 'pick-the-winner' trial — CT + CRT arm selected for phase 3 evaluation in resectable gastric cancer. Shifts attention back to preoperative chemoradiotherapy after CRITICS-I (phase 3) showed no benefit for postoperative CRT. Does not change current practice but informs phase 3 design.

CRITICS-II in the News

Key KOL Sentiments — CRITICS-II

DoctorSentimentComment
Dr Rishabh Jain ● NEUTRAL 🚨 Resectable Gastric Cancer | #GI26 CRITICS-II answers a key question What is the best preoperative strategy when adjuvant therapy is omitted? 🧪 Trial design Three fully neoadjuvant approaches compared ➡️ Chemotherapy alone ➡️ Chemotherapy → Chemoradiotherapy ➡️ https://t.co/iyxwxhge4n
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford ● NEUTRAL CRITICS-II: multicenter Ph2 RCT in resectable gastric ca showing preop chemo (DOC) + CRT improved 1-yr EFS &amp; pCR (20%) v CRT or chemo alone. But w D-FLOT now SOC, q’s are: 1. Could adding pre-op chemoRT to D-FLOT further improve pCR enabling organ pres option? #GI26 🧵1/2 https://t.co/XM2wkY8HiO
Dr Rishabh Jain ● NEUTRAL 📊 CRITICS-II at #ASCOGI26 Total neoadjuvant therapy wins the pre-op race in resectable gastric cancer 🍽️🩺 3 strategies tested head-to-head 🧪 Chemo alone 🔥 Chemoradiation alone 🚀 Chemo ➜ Chemoradiation (TNT) What stood out 👀 📈 1-yr EFS highest with TNT (84%) vs chemo https://t.co/QnKXR7YPUr https://t.co/NhlNretO8H
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford ● NEUTRAL Here is a great trial already in progress building off MATTERHORN &amp; CRITICS-II (presented today)! Japanese EPOC2031 Ph2: TNT for resectable GEJ -FLOT + pembro + short course RT (25 Gy/5fx) -1 endpt: EFS -Key 2nd endpts: organ pres &amp; QOL #GI26 @OncoAlert https://t.co/AuBHqKJthB https://t.co/fjpn7oLMfW
Garrett Green, MD ● NEUTRAL CRITICS - II: TNT for Gastric Cancer?! When do we consider chemorads #ASCOGI26 #GI26 https://t.co/bXjddANLlC
Nieves Martinez Lago MD PhD ● NEUTRAL #GI26 CRITICS-II (phase II) | Resectable GC 🔀 3 neoadj strategies tested (no adj therapy): • CT alone (failed EFS threshold) • CT → CRT (TNT) • CRT alone 📈 1-yr EFS: 84% (CT+CRT) vs 78% (CRT) vs 68% (CT) ➡️ CT+CRT selected for further study, incl. organ-sparing approaches https://t.co/B7Pq05AQ4l
Jun Gong ● NEUTRAL Dr. Hallemeier excellent discussion on CRITICS-II vs TOPGEAR, noting differences in absence of IO &amp; periop vs TNT approaches between studies including study heterogeneity. Important for further study &amp; great slide on scenarios where neoadj CRT may have a role @OncoAlert #GI26 https://t.co/sBbnbIVhG4
Jun Gong ● NEUTRAL Dr. Verheij CRITICS-II rand PhII pick-the-winner neoadj tx strategies in resectable #GC/GEJC ➡️ total neoadjuvant chemo + chemoRT w/best outcomes &amp; preferred candidate for further study, notably no adjuvant tx but addition of CRT to #chemoIO new avenue of study? @OncoAlert #GI26 https://t.co/VvfsOJejtE
Arndt Vogel ● NEUTRAL CRITICS-II: Phase II trial of neo-adjuvant CTx vs neo-adjuvant CTx and subsequent CTR vs neo-adjuvant chemoradiotherapy followed by surgery in resectable GC #ASCOGI26 👉 Arm1: lowest efficacy 👉 Arm2: longer OS 👉 Arm3: less tox 🧐 Arm 2 seems preferred option @myesmo @ASCO https://t.co/s1FKBVAGg4
Mustafa Özdoğan, MD ● NEUTRAL #ASCOGI26 | CRITICS-II (Abstract 283) Can we finally solve the post-op drop-out problem in gastric cancer? Total neoadjuvant therapy (chemo → chemoradiotherapy → surgery) shows higher 1-year EFS (84%) and OS (89%) versus single-modality approaches. But let’s pause before https://t.co/Qy3O5JuTBL
Dr. Nina Niu Sanford ● NEUTRAL Here is a great trial already in progress building off MATTERHORN &amp; CRITICS-II (presented today)! Japanese EPOC2031 Ph2: TNT for resectable GEJ -FLOT + pembro + short course RT (25 Gy/5fx) -1 endpt: EFS -Key 2nd endpts: organ pres &amp; QOL #GI26 @OncoAlert https://t.co/dji6fgqZe1 https://t.co/fjpn7oLMfW
Excellence in Oncology Care - EIOC ● NEUTRAL 👉trial conducted in an era where Dflot not standard of care. Furthermore now Matterhorn is standard of care 👉question is can chemoRT be integrated w/o compromising completion of modern intensified systemic therapies? #GI26 #ASCOGI26 #GastricCancer #OncologyResearch @OncoAlert https://t.co/q81TqVFCH0
Excellence in Oncology Care - EIOC ● NEUTRAL (1/2) This is an interesting trial: 👉CRITICS-II: multicenter Ph2 RCT in resectable gastric ca showing preop chemo (DOC) + CRT improved 1-yr EFS &amp; pCR (20%) v CRT or chemo alone. https://t.co/Vc8DMX0Syp
ドンナ@消化器外科医 ● NEUTRAL 🚨 切除可能胃がん | #GI26 CRITICS-II試験が重要な疑問に答える 👉 術後補助療法を行わない場合、最適な術前治療戦略は何か? ⸻ 🧪 試験デザイン 完全ネオアジュバント治療として、以下の3戦略を比較 ➡️ 化学療法(CT)のみ ➡️ 化学療法 → 化学放射線療法(CT → CRT) ➡️ https://t.co/YY12Cwqe3Y
Garrett Green, MD ● NEUTRAL CRITICS - II: TNT for Gastric Cancer?! When do we consider chemorads #ASCOGI26 https://t.co/cZN0xOmyDX